How to Confront the Elder Care Challenge
The service helped her find a good nursing home in North Carolina without her even having to set foot on an airplane. With the service’s help, she became the point person to gather information, while her older sister visited facilities with her father. Together with their other siblings, they formed a caregiver team. A year later, the service, Ceridian LifeWorks, helped Divers find home care and adult day care so her father could move out of the nursing home and live in his eldest daughter’s home.
Henderson-Divers is one of 44 million Americans engaged in the care of an older loved one. Fifteen to 25 percent of the workforce now care for older or disabled loved ones, and by 2010, the percentage is expected to double, according to Sandra Timmermann, director of the MetLife Mature Market Institute, the company’s information and policy resource center on issues related to aging, retirement, long-term care and the over-50 marketplace. Family caregivers struggle to balance their work and elder care obligations. This juggling act often affects a worker’s health, finances, and family and social life—and it results in lost productivity at work.
The cost to U.S. business from the lost productivity of working caregivers is more than $33 billion per year, according to the MetLife Caregiving Cost Study: Productivity Losses to U.S. Business. The average caregiver costs an employer $2,110 per year. The findings in the 2006 study represent an increase of about $4 billion in both categories from 1997, when the study was first conducted.
Working family caregivers tend to make informal adjustments, such as being late to work or leaving early, making incoming and outgoing telephone calls, and writing e-mails to arrange and monitor care and take unexpected days off. They also make formal adjustments. According to the 2006 Metlife caregiving study, at least six out of 10 employed caregivers reported that they had made some work-related adjustments as a result of their caregiving responsibilities. An estimated 9 percent of the caregivers who were employed left the workplace as a result of their caregiving responsibilities; 3 percent took early retirement and 6 percent left work entirely. An additional 10 percent of the employed caregivers reduced their hours from full time to part time.
Employees who are caregivers are most likely to be middle-aged and older workers who have accumulated the most expertise, skills and institutional memory, and are consequently the most expensive to replace. Caregiving can affect any worker—male or female, manager/supervisor, CEO, exempt or nonexempt. The problem can also be an invisible one. Employees often feel there is a stigma associated with being a caregiver and may not want to reveal this fact at work for fear that they could be fired, demoted or not promoted, according to Timmermann.
Employees don’t have to be caregivers to be affected by caregiving. Co-workers and managers who are caregivers often affect the work environment and workload for others. The growth of the number of caregivers in the workforce is a trend that will not go away soon. The companies that will thrive in the future will adapt to this reality by implementing or strengthening HR policies and practices that improve both a company’s bottom line and the lives of employee caregivers, Timmermann says.
Pioneering companies like IBM are trying to mitigate the negative impact caregiving has on employees through a number of interventions. Beginning in 1987, IBM partnered with Work/Family Directions, which is now part of Ceridian, to develop the first national corporate elder care program.
IBM realized that elder care was a need similar to child care for its workers, and took what it learned from its child care resource referral services and applied it to elder care, says Maria Ferris, director of workforce diversity programs at IBM.
"The big difference between child and elder care is that the elder care programs have changed," she says. "Elder care started out as resource and referral, but now includes a variety of offerings that not only provide timely information to caregivers, but also training on how to be a better caregiver."
With the American Business Collaboration for Dependent Care, IBM piloted Powerful Tools for Caregivers, an online course to help family caregivers develop the skills to better look after themselves while caring for others. The course was developed by Mather Lifeways, a nonprofit organization providing educational programs and services for older adults and their caregivers. An evaluation of the pilot found that participants in the course experienced improved self-confidence and decreased feelings of depression and work-related stress.
IBM’s other elder care offerings include six hours per year of paid elder services such as care management. A care manager is a geriatric nurse practitioner and/or social worker who conducts home assessments, develops an individualized home care plan, or researches the availability, costs and quality of alternative housing such as assisted living and nursing homes. This person often arranges and monitors the delivery of services, which enables employee caregivers to better focus on their jobs, save time and aggravation, and gain peace of mind.
"We offered care management services in addition to the resource and referral program because taking care of an older relative involves enormous complexity around financial, legal and health issues such as Medicare and Medicaid," says Jennifer Piliero, product manager for Ceridian’s LifeWorks.
"The care management service is a higher-touch program, involving more in-person guidance, problem solving and navigation. Helping a loved one find a nursing home or assistance with a care-related issue is an overwhelming, intimidating decision to make, in which you feel an enormous sense of responsibility that often has to be made in a short period of time," Piliero says.
Other employer-sponsored elder care services can include such low-cost interventions as leave-sharing programs, distributing information about community services via an intranet and corporate newsletters, or moderate interventions such as caregiver fairs and "lunch and learn" sessions. More expensive interventions include paid family leave, a free or subsidized care manager and support groups offered at the company.
Some employers are adding new services to enhance offerings with the focus on better meeting caregiver needs and building resilience. These include intergenerational daycare centers, concierge services, and tele-health products, such as two-way interactive video that allows an adult child or nurses to monitor an older person’s health and safety. Time Inc. just began offering a medical-decision support program that gets employees in touch with a medical researcher and a physician who share the latest research about diseases such as cancer or Alzheimer’s.
The law firm of Fulbright & Jaworski offers backup care services, which are the fastest-growing segment of dependent care programs and are increasingly used for elder care. The Work Options Group, another backup service vendor, has observed that backup care services for adults and elders have tripled in 2006.
"Offering benefits such as backup care has greatly enhanced overall employee morale," says Jane Williams, chief human resources officer for Fulbright & Jaworski. "It allows employees to know, no matter the distance, there is an option to make sure those they love get the care they need when the unexpected occurs. Just knowing that the safety net is there has relieved a lot of stress for many people," Williams says.
Obstacles: struggling in silence, not seeking help
HR professionals are in a pivotal position to introduce effective and inexpensive solutions to help employers contain costs and retain workers, while helping employees who juggle job and family caregiving duties. Yet, many HR professional are experiencing significant obstacles serving this group. On one hand, there are employees who are nervous about asking for help; and on the other are employees who don’t take advantage of what a company offers.
Employee caregivers often say they are reluctant to talk about caregiving and work conflicts, or have difficulty getting managers to understand the problems they face, says John Paul Marosy, author of A Manager's Guide to Elder Care and Work and president of Bring Elder Care Home, a training and consulting firm.
"There is a stigma associated with caregiving, linked to fears of retribution and ageism if they do come forward," he says. For example, one employee told her supervisor that she could not come to work for a few days because she had lice. In actuality, she was afraid to tell her supervisor that she needed to travel out of state to pick up her mother, who just had a stroke and needed her care.
There is a need for management training about elder care. "Managers can have their head in the sand, and frequently are unaware of the negative impact caregiving is having on work, nor are they aware of company-sponsored supports and community resources that could help mitigate the strain on employee caregivers," Marosy says. A manager’s awareness and openness to caregiver pressures can have a significant impact on an employee.
"My supervisor is supportive of me taking time off, and asks me sincerely about how my mother is feeling and encourages me to do what I need to do for my mother as long as the work gets done somehow," says June Ninnemann, an employee caregiver. "You don’t have to pretend you’re sick; you just take the day off when you are needed."
Meanwhile, some human resources managers are frustrated because some employee caregivers don’t pay attention to elder care benefit education and outreach until they are immersed in their unforgiving role and are "burning out," or there is a sudden health crisis with their older relative.
"Role reversals, family histories and confronting your relatives’ or your own mortality makes it very uncomfortable for employees to raise caregiver issues at work," says Diane Piktialis, research working group leader at the Conference Board. "Some workers feel it is not a legitimate work/life concern and they underestimate the obligation they face, or wrap themselves in denial."
Only 2 percent to 3 percent of eligible employees on average actually access elder care benefits in any given year, according to Piktialis, but the onus isn’t just on the employees to enroll, she says.
"Good intentions are not enough to increase participation rates," Piktialis says. "You have to continually market programs that support caregivers, and show real examples how the programs are working to gain employees trust.,"
Cost-Effectiveness And Making The Business Case
To initiate, expand or justify elder care and work/life benefits, an HR professional may need to make a strong business case. The reality is, however, that although some companies have monitored costs, benefits and utilization rates for elder care programs, none have actually evaluated return on investment. Only a few companies have evaluated ROI for work/life programs in general. According to the Alliance for Work-Life Progress survey "State of the Worklife Profession," only 8 percent of employers measured all of their work/life programs for ROI, 43 percent of employers measured certain work/life programs for ROI, and 49 percent of employers measured none of their worklife programs for ROI.
There has been research that shows how work/life programs can reduce employee turnover, increase productivity and decrease absenteeism and health care costs, according to the Families and Work Institute, a nonprofit research organization that addresses the changing nature of work and family life. There are also a number of formulas for determining ROI for work/life programs. An Alliance for Work-Life Progress publication, The Categories of Work-life Effectiveness, provides ROI proof points, for example.
Some work/life and HR professionals argue that it is not worth the time, money and effort to conduct ROI evaluations for elder care programs.
"Bottom-line, number-driven analysis is not always the most effective way to evaluate elder care benefits. We should also focus on what’s being accomplished in terms of such things as reduced stress and improved performance and loyalty, and not only dollar return on investment," says Karol Rose, chief marketing officer of a new Web site called Flexpaths, which has tools and resources for employers and individuals to improve their use of all aspects of work flexibility. "It’s important not to hold benefits like elder care to a higher standard than, say, medical benefits in terms of developing ROI metrics."
Offering elder care programs is relatively inexpensive, Ceridian’s Piliero says. Pricing for work/life programs in general varies, based on the level of service an employer wants and the size of the organization. Fees range from around $5 to $12 per employee per year. Piliero says that the cost per person for just adult and elder care management services is $1.40 to $2, and utilization rates of care management typically are 0.15 percent to 0.25 percent of the employee population, depending on demographics and how much communication is used to promote the care management resource. Piliero makes the point that utilization rates may be low, but time saved is high for care management services, rendering it a low-use but high-impact service.
"Offering elder benefits is often low cost, but has high internal and external value," says Teri Lukin, director of health services and work life initiatives at Time Inc. Lukin stresses that a good work/life program, with resource and referral capabilities, is very important. "Other benefits fill niches, but resource and referral is the framework," she says.
According to the Alliance for Work-Life Progress, employers who encourage usage of a wide variety of work/life programs document greater bottom-line results. Particularly when serving employee caregivers, employers need an array of services to support a variety of caregiver needs.
"To be most effective in supporting elder-care givers, employers need to take a two-pronged approach: offer work/life benefits that help employees better manage family and other caregiving commitments, and help employees better manage their time at work and their workload," says Judith Presser, senior consultant at WFD Consulting, a work/life consulting firm that coordinates the American Business Collaborative’s activities, such as the Powerful Tools for Caregivers program. "More companies are beginning to understand the importance of allowing employees to manage how and where the work gets done and how to increase employees' control over their workload," she says.
HR professionals face the challenge of developing cost-effective responses to caregiver needs at a time when corporate budgets are growing ever tighter and employee health benefits costs are increasing at a double-digit rate. But the alternative might be worse.
"Many businesses are now realizing that they have to do something to help their employees who are caregivers because doing nothing may be more costly, says Timmermann at the MetLife Mature Market Institute. According to Timmermann, caregivers in the workplace will not disappear, but in fact will grow in importance and affect families, employees, supervisors and employers for years.
"Most employers and employees underestimate or deny the growing negative impact family caregiving has at work, but the tide is beginning to change," Timmermann says. "MetLife’s study on productivity losses associated with caregiving is a wake-up call to the business community. It’s not a matter of whether businesses will face productivity issues related to elder care, but when and how they will effectively respond."