 |
Reports Differ on Employee Satisfaction
Kelly survey says 66 percent of women and 62 percent of males are happy or very happy with their job; Sibson reports that career satisfaction dropped from 61 percent in 2003 to 41 percent this year.
December 8, 2006
Reports Differ on Employee Satisfaction
Most American employees are happy with their work and give
high marks to their bosses, according to a new survey from Kelly Services that
goes against the conventional thinking.
U.S.,
participated in the Kelly Global Workforce Index report.
U.S. workers are among the happiest in the world,
according to the survey, trailing Denmark, Mexico and Sweden. The
prospects, however, are not as good for countries like Hungary, Russia and Turkey, where
less than 50 percent of respondents say they are happy with their jobs. Not
only are U.S. workers happy with their jobs,
but they also give high marks to their bosses. Managers were evaluated on their
ability to communicate, delegate responsibilities, generate a team spirit and
exert leadership. On a scale of 1 to 10, employees in the U.S.
gave an average rating of 7.3 to their bosses. That mark is only second to the
7.6 that Mexican workers give to their supervisors.
But there is still room
for improvement. The levels of happiness among workers varied according to
industry. Only 37 percent of respondents who work in retail, for example, say
they are happy with their job. There are other areas of concern as well. Almost
30 percent of workers say they are rarely or never rewarded for a job well
done.
“The challenge is to continually provide interesting and
meaningful work as well as opportunities for employees to learn and more fully
develop their own skills,” says George Corona, senior vice president at
Kelly.
The results of the Kelly survey provide a refreshing change from other
studies, which depict a much more depressed, unhappy and unengaged workforce.
Sibson, a human resources consulting firm, released a study last month
indicating that workers are less satisfied and less engaged. According to the
report, career satisfaction dropped from 61 percent in 2003 to 41 percent this
year.
The Kelly and Sibson surveys don’t use the same yardstick to measure
results, but the divergence in their findings could make it confusing for
employers to trying to understand the psychology of their workforce. Regardless
of whether a survey portrays a workforce that is happy or one that is not,
what's important is for employers to strive toward enhancing practices that are
known to make a positive difference in the workplace, Corona says.
“Time and again, workers tell us that they want a workplace
with good morale, stimulating work, a degree of autonomy and meaningful feedback
from their bosses,” he says.
--Gina Ruiz
|