A change in leadership on Capitol Hill, a looming
presidential campaign and a renewed sense of urgency about health care reform
have brought together unusual alliances in Washington designed to achieve
universal coverage.
In mid-January, 16 diverse national organizations—ranging
from Families USA to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce—came together as the Health
Coverage Coalition for the Uninsured and introduced recommendations for
extending health care to 47 million uninsured Americans.
Earlier the same week, AARP, the Business Roundtable and the
Service Employees International Union formed Divided We Fail, whose mission is
to promote universal access to health care and long-term financial security.
Each group says it’s motivated by a desire to reduce health
care costs, address social injustice, influence Congress and shape the
presidential campaign agenda. Their leitmotif is similar: If we can work
together, so can politicians.
“Peace is breaking out all over. Partnership is breaking out
all over,” SEIU president Andy Stern says.
William Novelli, AARP’s chief executive, says, “People are
open to change, and now is the opportunity to create it.”
The Health Coverage Coalition for the Uninsured is offering a
two-part initiative. First, it would address the issue of the 9 million children
who lack health coverage by making it easier for low-income families to enroll
in a federal children’s insurance program. Families whose income is up to 300
percent of the federal poverty level would receive tax credits to buy
insurance.
For uninsured adults, the group would expand Medicaid
eligibility for low-income people and provide a refundable tax credit for higher
earners.
On Capitol Hill, a steady stream of health care proposals is
flowing. Sen. Ron Wyden, D-Oregon, introduced a bill that would enable private
insurers to cover individuals directly. Companies would pay the government a
health care contribution, rather than insure employees themselves.
Sen. Edward Kennedy, D-Massachusetts, favors achieving
universal coverage by expanding Medicare. A bipartisan group has introduced a
bill that would establish a commission to award grants to states to fund their
own coverage ideas. And in his State of the Union address last week, President
Bush proposed a standard health insurance tax deduction of up to $15,000.
“Changing the tax code is a vital and necessary step to making health care
affordable for more Americans,” he said.
As momentum builds, some in the business community worry that
employers will end up footing the bill for additional coverage.
Corporate members of the health care coalition, however,
assert that their plan would help low-income employees afford insurance,
reducing billions of dollars of uncompensated costs that foster higher
premiums.
“There are no mandates here,” says Robert Darretta, vice
chairman of Johnson & Johnson. “We’re strong advocates of incentives. What
we’re proposing is a helping hand.”
Expanding coverage could ultimately lower corporate health
care bills because costs related to the uninsured are eventually borne by those
who do provide coverage—companies.
“That needs to get addressed, no matter what [else] happens,”
says Dan Ustian, president and CEO of Navistar International Corp.
How the debate unfolds depends on often elusive congressional
political will. That’s why some members want to help more states follow the
health care path blazed by Massachusetts and California.
“Congress is not going to act in a major way to deal with
this access problem in the next couple years,” says Sen. Jeff Bingaman, D-New
Mexico.
—Mark Schoeff Jr.