As SAP battles for a bigger share of companies’ HR software
spending, collaboration is its watchword.
During its April user conference in Atlanta, the Germany-based
software firm announced that it is developing tools to help workers team up in
informal ways, such as with wikis—Web sites where people can discuss a problem.
It also claimed that the key to business success these days is better
cooperation among customers, suppliers, partners and employees. In keeping with
this theme, SAP professes to be committed to working closely with its own
customers and partners.
Chief executive Henning Kagermann emphasized this approach in the
close of his keynote speech. "Please talk to us," Kagermann said. "Give us
feedback."
SAP isn’t alone in promoting collaboration both inside and beyond
a company’s walls as a vital business tool. For at least a couple of years, the
phrase "extended enterprise" has been in vogue. The growing open-source software
movement also has highlighted the promise of widely distributed cooperation.
SAP’s teamwork push comes as it faces challenges. It reported
lower-than-expected earnings for the quarter ended March 31. In late March, the
company announced the departure of one of its key executives, Shai Agassi,
president of SAP’s product and technology group. And while SAP is one of the top
sellers of HR software worldwide, it faces stiff competition. That includes
archrival Oracle, which recently sued SAP for allegedly stealing Oracle tech
support materials.
What’s more, SAP—along with other software companies—has had a
reputation for haughtiness. SAP was said to stand for "Shut up And Pay." (The
SAP acronym officially comes from the company’s initial name in 1972: Systems,
Applications and Products in Data Processing.)
The cynical might say that SAP’s embrace of "co-innovation" is
little more than marketing hype to prop up its image. But a number of observers
say the firm’s collaboration quest appears to be genuine.
"They certainly have identified the need to be more cooperative,"
says Christa Degnan Manning, an analyst at AMR Research who studies human
resources-related software. Degnan Manning says close communication with
customers and partners is especially important in the area of SAP’s human
resource software. There’s a limited pool of people who have thought about
making HR processes more business-focused, and a still smaller number who have
both that "strategic" HR mind-set and familiarity with SAP applications, she
says.
Nov Omana, founder of consulting firm Collective HR Solutions,
sees a new willingness to listen, both at SAP and at Oracle. Omana points to
Oracle’s "Accelerate" program for small and medium-sized firms as an example of
the software maker tapping its partners’ expertise.
But can collaboration morph into exploitation? What if software
vendors take great ideas from customers without any compensation? Omana, for
one, says that’s the wrong way to look at it. The consultant, who is past
chairman of the International Association for Human Resource Information
Management professional group, says that customers who help vendors improve
their software ultimately realize the benefit.
"By you solving this particular problem, the vendor is able to put
their development dollars toward other problems," he says.
—Ed Frauenheim
Read more about SAP and HR technology.
Click here to comment on this story.