Defined-benefit pension plans have spent the past few years recovering from
the collapse of the tech bubble.
Now plan sponsors are watching as the credit crunch undermines not only
equity prices, but also the alternative assets that many plans have piled into,
like private equity and hedge funds.
Michael Wright, a principal at Buck Consulting, said that while it’s far too
early for plan sponsors to have made any changes in their asset allocations in
response to the recent market moves, he is seeing nervousness among plan
sponsors who were considering putting assets into alternative investments.
While plans have done stress testing of 130/30 funds or the arbitrage
strategies used by hedge funds, “certainly what has happened in the last few
months, the volatility that came through here, was outside the parameters of the
model,” Wright says. “People who were thinking of putting those in, that’s where
we hear ‘We need to reassess this.’
“I know of at least one plan sponsor that was going through a total
bundled-vendor search and said, ‘We want to test this without the hedge fund and
some of the commodity exposure,’ ” he adds.
Wright says some plan sponsors have been surprised to see where problems
showed up in their holdings, as the subprime fallout affected not only
mortgage-backed securities but the stocks of financial firms and home
builders.
“When you do an asset/liability modeling study for a large plan sponsor after
this event,” he says, “the correlation assumptions about asset classes are going
to be questioned.”
Filed by Susan Kelly of Financial Week, a sister publication of Workforce
Management. To comment, e-mail editors@workforce.com.