An employee whose doctor recommended that he use marijuana cannot claim
disability-based discrimination against an employer that fired him for testing
positive for drug consumption, a split California Supreme Court ruled Thursday,
January 24.
The plaintiff in Gary Ross v. Ragingwire Telecommunications Inc. claimed that
his former employer violated California’s anti-discrimination law when the
employer fired him rather than make accommodations for a disability.
At issue in the case was whether California’s Compassionate Use Act of 1996
would override an employer’s policy against drug use, court records show. The
1996 act approved by voters provides a criminal defense in cases where a doctor
recommends marijuana use for medical purposes.
But nothing in the act “suggests the voters intended the measure to address
the respective rights and duties of employers and employees,” justices stated in
the 5-2 decision. The state high court therefore upheld lower court rulings that
found the plaintiff could not use the act as an argument to pursue a disability
discrimination lawsuit against his employer.
Ross did not state what accommodation he sought, so the court justices
inferred he desired that the employer waive its drug policy to allow his use of
marijuana at home, the opinion states.
Ross suffers from back strain, muscle spasms and chronic pain from an injury
suffered while serving in the Air Force. The injury qualifies him as a
“qualified individual” under California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act, court
records state.
But he was terminated from his job after he failed a drug test shortly after
he was hired in 2001 as a lead system operator for Ragingwire
Telecommunications.
The court’s minority found that the majority’s decision lacked compassion for
holding that an employer may fire an ailing employee when their medical
marijuana use does not impair their job performance or their employer’s
interests.
Filed by Roberto Ceniceros of Business Insurance, a sister publication of
Workforce Management. To comment, e-mail editors@workforce.com.