A government proposal for streamlining the hiring process for foreign
agricultural workers could make life easier for employers but also increase the
costs and hassles of maintaining a workforce for harvesting crops.
Regulatory changes announced in early February by the Departments of Labor,
Homeland Security and Agriculture would reduce the limitations and delays
associated with H-2A visas for temporary farmhands.
The effort is another attempt at immigration reform through regulation now
that broad legislation appears to be dead on Capitol Hill.
The new rules would let employers apply for H-2As directly with the Labor
Department rather than having to file both federal and state requests. Other
provisions would make it easier for farmers to submit blanket petitions for
thousands of workers, facilitate workers’ switching employers and traveling to
their home countries, and link H-2A wages to occupation, skill level and local
market conditions.
To demonstrate the government is cracking down on illegal employment,
companies would have to increase recruiting and advertising efforts to prove
that they can’t find American workers to pick fruits and vegetables.
In addition, employers would have to sign up for a government-run electronic
employment verification system to take full advantage of the H-2A reforms. They
also would be subject to stronger workforce audits and fines of up to $100,000
for hiring violations.
The public has until late March to comment on the proposed changes. A final
rule may go into effect by August.
It’s not clear whether employers will benefit or be set back by the
regulatory changes, according to Hector Chichoni, manager of the East Coast
immigration practice at Squire, Sanders and Demp¬sey in Miami.
“Everything depends on how they implement it,” Chichoni says. “In the long
run, you can see a reduction in costs; in the short run, I’m not so sure. Every
time you have bureaucrats dealing with the market, it is complex.”
For instance, Chichoni is concerned that one important agency was left out of
the reform announcement.
“There was no presence from the Department of
State,” he says. He wonders whether consulates will change their rules for
approving H-2A visas.
Federal officials who promulgated the regulations touted them as a way to
curb illegal immigration, protect legal employees and help farmers, who have
been straining from labor shortages while crops rot in the field.
Of the 1.2 million agricultural workers in the U.S., about 600,000 to 800,000
are illegal. Even though the program is uncapped, only 75,000 H-2A visas were
used in 2007.
“The changes we are proposing will go a long way toward ensuring that
America’s farmers will have a stable, legal workforce that they can … count on
at harvest time,” says Charles Conner, deputy secretary of agriculture.
But immigration proponents condemn the rule changes, asserting that they will
result in lower wages and poor working conditions for foreign workers.
“The administration has further undercut them with this regulation,” says
Cecelia Munoz, vice president for research, advocacy and legislation at the
National Council of La Raza.
—Mark Schoeff Jr.