Few employers have wanted to risk advancing interest-free money to help
employees pay medical bills. Edward Jones, the St. Louis-based financial
investment firm, is one exception.
The company in 2006 devised a way to help employees pay unexpected medical
bills by advancing cash interest-free from future paychecks. The money would
otherwise have been deducted from their paychecks during the course of the year
and deposited into individual health savings accounts. The service helped calm
employees’ fears of not being able to pay for the high deductible, which is
$2,500 for individuals and $5,000 for families in one of the plans the company
offers.
“The No. 1 concern we heard from our associates was, ‘I don’t have $2,500
January 1st if I’m hit by a bus,’ ” said Andy Greenberg, principal of HR
programs. “They were worried by that. This takes the worry out of having an
unpredictable health care event.”
The money is advanced automatically when an employee pays for a health care
bill with a Visa-branded HSA debit card. If the account is empty, money is drawn
from an Edward Jones account. The debt is paid back through automatic payroll
deductions that would otherwise have deposited a portion of a person’s paycheck
into his or her health savings account.
The service is perhaps the biggest reason enrollment in these plans is high,
Greenberg said. Although the company has a low-deductible plan, 77 percent of
employees are enrolled in one of two high-deductible plans. About half of the
employees across income levels have taken advances on their health savings
account deposits.
Not having enough cash to pay a medical bill has been an unpleasant reality
faced by many employees on high-deductible health plans. Though banks have
capitalized by offering credit, the prospect of adding to a person’s debt has
troubled some employers.
Still, advancing health care money is unusual, said Jay Savan, a consultant
with Towers Perrin, which counts Edward Jones as a client, and has not been
adopted by other employers for a number of reasons.
“The people that do [need the money], generally speaking, are not going to
have good credit, and employers don’t necessarily want to underwrite it,” he
said.
E-Duction in Blue Bell, Pennsylvania, offers a general-interest credit
card that can be used for health care. The card’s debt is paid back through
payroll deduction, and the loan is based on a percentage of a person’s salary.
Paul Chicos, president and CEO of the company, said 85 percent of his 20,000
cardholders have subprime credit scores.
“Employers should be willing to guarantee loans from banks,” Chicos said,
“because the money is coming out of payroll deduction.”
Though Edward Jones says it doesn’t provide credit, it does face a risk
advancing a person’s paycheck. Employees who leave the company may never repay
their debt.
“If someone leaves, we’re out the money,” Greenberg said. “We ask them to pay
us. A large majority do; if they don’t, we don’t turn them over to a collection
agency. We report it as taxable income and write off the loss.”
The company says it decided it would rather take the loss than add to
people’s consumer debt. But that could pose a particular problem for companies
with high turnover, Savan said. Companies are finding that most employees have
saved enough by the end of the first year to have money in their account if they
are faced with an unexpected medical bill early the next year, he said.
“By the time a plan is 2 or 3 years old, most people have accumulated some
kind of balance,” he said.
—Jeremy Smerd
Workforce Management's online news feed is now available via Twitter.