Nearly half of New York City’s workforce—about 1.9 million New
Yorkers—don’t get paid sick leave, according to a new study by the Community
Service Society of New York, a nonprofit advocacy group for the poor.
Low-income workers are nearly twice as likely as higher-income workers to
receive no paid sick days, with 66 percent of workers earning less than $36,000
a year for a family of three lacking the benefit, according to the study.
More than seven in 10 low-income workers without paid sick leave reported
going to work sick in the past year, while three in 10 reported sending a sick
child to school because they could not take time off from work, the study
shows.
The portion of workers in households earning $18,000 to $36,000 annually for
a family of three has declined as the economy has tanked. Only 33 percent
received paid sick leave in 2009, compared with 43 percent the year before and
56 percent in 2007.
The survey comes as a bill that would compel employers to provide workers
with paid sick days wends its way through the City Council.
Under the measure, employers with 10 or more workers would have to provide
nine paid sick days, while companies with fewer than 10 workers would have to
give five. The city’s five chambers of commerce have raised opposition to the
measure, arguing it would place an unfair burden on businesses during tough
economic times.
“It’s really low-income workers who are affected the most,” said New York
City Councilwoman Gale Brewer, the bill’s lead sponsor.
Low-income Latino workers are most likely to be without paid sick days, the
study shows, with seven in 10 not receiving any paid sick leave. Authors of the
report attributed this to the fact that Latinos are less likely than blacks or
whites to be union members.
Workers without paid sick leave are concentrated in the leisure, hospitality,
and retail and wholesale trade sectors, which account for two-thirds of workers
who don’t get the benefit, according to the study.
Small businesses are least likely to provide paid sick leave, the study
shows.
For instance, nearly two-thirds of workers in businesses with 10 or fewer
employees do not receive paid sick leave—as compared with only 18 percent of
workers in large businesses with 500 or more employees. Those in businesses with
10 or fewer employees represent more than a quarter of all working New Yorkers
without paid sick leave.
“For those that don’t offer five days or more, it is most likely that they
simply couldn’t afford to stay in business if they did,” wrote Carl Hum and
Nancy Ploeger, heads of the Brooklyn and Manhattan chambers, in a recent issue
of Crain’s New York Business, a sister publication of Workforce Management.
Mayor Michael Bloomberg has said he supports paid sick leave for large
companies, but has stopped short of embracing it for small ones. His rival, City
Comptroller William Thompson, has said he supported paid sick days, but that
“one size does not fit all.”
Council Speaker Christine Quinn has yet to take a position.
Brewer said that she has met with many small business owners and
representatives of the chambers and is eager to include them in the legislative
process.
“There’s lots of room for compromise,” she said. “But the basic issue is, if
you’re sick, you should be able to stay home.”
Filed by Daniel Massey
of Crain’s New
York Business, a sister publication of Workforce
Management. To comment, e-mail
editors@workforce.com.
Stay informed and
connected. Get human resources news and HR features via Workforce Management’s Twitter feed
or RSS feeds for mobile devices and news
readers.