The employee reaction after the switch was far from positive. According to Kraft, the district experienced difficulties with plan providers, customer service was poor and the volume of complaints was considerable. Soon after, Kraft realized the change was not worth it. "We were so used to the exceptional service from VSP. It’s very hard to duplicate that. The members were so dissatisfied and it takes a lot of time to handle employee complaints. I ended up spending a large portion of my time handling employee complaints."

    Kraft is emphatic that the cost savings was not worth the hassle. "If the price had been a third or a quarter of VSP’s cost, it still wouldn’t have been worth it to switch carriers. I’ve learned a hard lesson, that you get what you pay for."

International Network Services, Inc.
    Another "boomerang" client, Santa Clara, California based International Network Services, Inc. (INS), a leading vendor-independent provider of global network consulting and security services, became a VSP client in 1998, but switched to another vision carrier after being acquired by Lucent Technologies, Inc. With the switch came a dramatic change for INS employees. Julie Threet, INS’s Director of Compensation and Benefits acknowledges "after the switch, vision became one of the biggest employee issues."

    Their new vision benefit had a large chain component, and Threet says her employees missed VSP’s large doctor network and member service features. "Our engineers travel all the time based on their assignment and can’t be constricted by chains. They are technical and want to know they can go to a Web site and find a doctor they can see in the city they are in. They want their spouse to have the same experience at home."

    With the heavy chain emphasis of the new benefit, Threet and her employees were also concerned about the quality of the care they were receiving. "We didn’t like going to the same place to have our eyes checked where we buy laundry detergent."

    By the time INS was spun-off in 2002, Threet says "VSP was the first plan we knew we wanted to re-instate."

    Both employees and benefit administrators at INS applauded the change back to VSP. "Based on my experience with VSP, we’ve never had an issue with cost, administration or employee satisfaction. The last thing I want my engineers doing, is tracking down a claim issue instead of billing clients. That is how we generate revenue. Any time the employee spends worrying about their benefits, is valuable time away from their work. With VSP, I don’t have to worry about it."

"Based on my experience with VSP, we've never had an issue with cost, administration or employee satisfaction."--INS Director of Compensation and Benefits, Julie Threet