 |
Human Resource Executive's Ninth Annual HR Technology Conference & Exposition
October 4-6, 2006, Navy Pier, Chicago
Event: Human Resource Executive's Ninth Annual HR Technology Conference &
Exposition
Date: October 4-6, 2006, Navy Pier, Chicago
What: Described by its organizers as "the world's leading conference
on all aspects of technology for HR executives and professionals," the HR Technology
Conference brings together 200-plus technology vendors in the exhibit hall and
a wide variety of technology-related seminars and speakers.
Conference info: For more information about the HR
Technology Conference
Conference Notes, Day 3—Friday, October 6
Free speech? There is a certain tone and patter to most trade shows and conferences. In fact, there is such a sameness that sometimes the only differences are the quality of the speakers, the venue and maybe some of the parties and after-hours events. The HR Technology Conference generally followed normal conference style and was, for the most part, a pretty typical gathering.
But, there were a couple odd things:
- Trying to squelch a presenter's comments because they might undercut
another conference the show's organizer is putting on. During the industry
analyst panel on Day 2, the moderator urged panelist Naomi Lee Bloom, managing
partner of Bloom & Wallace, not to say too much in response to a question
about business process outsourcing, and instead, to "just tease the audience"
so people would want to come and hear what she has to say on the subject at
the HRO World conference in New York City next spring.
- Chiding a presenter because her comments weren't vendor-friendly. Again,
during the Day 2 industry analyst panel, the same moderator chided Lisa Rowan
of IDC when she suggested that "we need more (industry) consolidation because
we have too many competitors" in the HR technology sector. The implication
was that her comments would in some way have an impact on the number of exhibitors
at future HR Technology Conferences.
But Rowan stuck her guns on the need for industry consolidation, and was supported by Bloom, who agreed that there are just "too many vendors who don't have a truly integrated suite (of products)." Bloom told the moderator: "Don't worry. Next year there will be some new category with a whole new set of vendors."
(Full disclosure: Human Resource Executive magazine, the organizer of the
HR Technology Conference, competes against Workforce Management. But the
panel-control techniques would be weird even if the magazine wasn't a competitor.)
Friday breakout sessions: Friday was a short conference wrap-up day, so there was just one group of breakout sessions.
Loree Farrar, VP for global rewards at Yahoo, and Wally Smith, president and CEO of Enwisen, an HR communications company, gave a good look into how even a technology-based company like Yahoo had to go outside to find a vendor to better communicate the total rewards and benefits picture to its employees. By giving all the Yahoos a clearer presentation of the company's contribution to their personal bottom lines, the company lowered voluntary turnover, increased 401(k) enrollment and even implemented some cost-sharing for medical in a positive way.
Friday keynote: Bloom wrapped up the conference with her talk "It's the Technology, Stupid!" Her main point: If you are buying new technology for your company, be skeptical of the vendor's sales pitch. She said you should trust what they say, but only with verification. "When someone says, 'No problem, we can do that,' your follow-up response should be, 'Thank you. I'd like to see that.'" Research, testing, doing your homework and lots of questions are the only way to get the technology that best serves your needs, she said.
Bloom had a good speech and a great message, but it's too bad she was scheduled to give it at the very end of the conference, when there were so few people left to hear it.
—John Hollon
Conference Notes, Day 2—Thursday October
5, 2006
Morning general session, Day 2: The late-arriving
early-morning crowd got to hear four analysts (Naomi Lee Bloom of Bloom & Wallace,
Paul Hamerman of Forrester Research, Jim Holincheck of Gartner and Lisa Rowan
of IDC) talk on industry tends in HR technology—particularly business process
outsourcing. Some of the highlights:
- Early BPO deals have gone well, for the most part. Companies are generally happy with these deals, Rowan says, but there are some margin difficulties (profitability issues) for BPO providers due to the complexity of the deals, particularly with the early BPO deals. BPO deals will become more profitable for providers, but it will take time.
- Oracle has been doing good things lately with its Fusion and Applications Unlimited initiatives, according to Hamerman, particularly in the support of applications moving ahead without forcing an upgrade. He did say, however, that Oracle might be charging a bit too much for maintenance and risks losing customers to SAP or Lawson as a result.
- On technology being a "magic bullet" for HR, Bloom said: "Companies that have always done a good job without technology (in their HR practices) will find that technology will be a big help, but if you haven't done a good job, there's nothing on the showroom floor that will help."
- Holincheck asked, "How does an industry survive where nobody is making money?" To change this, he says, the industry needs a standard set of services that BPO vendors and customers agree on, with a standard list of technologies below that.
The future for BPO? As Rowan put it: "We need more consolidation. We just have too many competitors."
Industry shootout: On of the more interesting sessions is the "shootout" between vendors showing how their technology would solve a series of basic business problems given to all the vendors involved in the exercise, with the audience voting on which product performed the best.
The Thursday-morning session ("The First Integrated Performance & Learning Management Shootout") drew another overflow crowd and matched Saba, Plateau Systems, Cornerstone on Demand and Knowledge Planet on building development goals and activities to support a performance plan, including job development and succession planning.
There were four different tests for the four companies to run through, and about halfway through the shootout it got a little confusing remembering what each company's software had done. Still, it was an interesting side-by-side comparison of how well these performance management products work. The winner? It was Plateau Systems, although Cornerstone on Demand made a strong showing as well.
Most intriguing session: The afternoon session on "Hot New Technologies for HR" was even more crowded than most of the breakout seminars—probably because attendees wanted to see what these hot new technologies were. Unfortunately, the technologies they were talking about (podcasting and blogging) weren't quite so hot or new (so much for truth in advertising), but the session was still informative, including:
- Using blogging as a recruiting tool. Steve Rothberg of Collegerecruiter.com called blogging a "powerful recruiting tool" for companies in telling prospective employees more about what they do inside after someone gets hired. He listed three rules for the success of any blog: 1) High-quality content; 2) Blogging frequently (better not do one than to do it on an infrequent schedule); and 3) Blogging regularly (once per week minimum, with three to four times per week being best).
- Video games as a marketing tool. Scott Randall of BrandGames talked about using custom video games to engage prospective employees and to use in training new employees. He pointed to Arrow Electronics' use of a video game for would-be or new employees and how it helps to immerse them in the history and culture of Arrow.
- Video and podcasts for succession management and workforce development. David Fabianski of Pearson Performance Solutions showed examples of Pearson's "50 Lessons" series, in which business leaders share their knowledge and wisdom in a brief video. The benefit? "We capture the essence of the human experience through storytelling," Fabianski says.
—John Hollon
Conference Notes, Day 1—Wednesday October 4, 2006
Show basics: The HR Technology Conference is a good one to
attend if you want to maximize your exposure to HR technology in one fell swoop.
With 213 booths in the exhibit hall, and somewhere in the neighborhood of 1,500
attendees, it's one of the largest gatherings of people interested in HR technology.
The seminars seem to be an especially big draw, with overflow crowds at just
about every one we attended. They were broken up into five basic tracks:
- Strategic view
- Performance and compensation management
- HRMS, portals and self-service
- Recruiting
- Outsourcing
The structure of the seminars made it impossible for anyone to attend all of
them, or even most of them, and the conference organizers made note of this
by urging attendees to bring "more of your colleagues next year so you can cover
them all." Nice idea, but at a steep $1,345 per person to attend (early registration
discounts were available), we’re not sure how many companies would take
them up on that.
Keynote speaker, Day 1: Stanford Business School professor (and Business
2.0 columnist) Jeffrey Pfeffer talked about making evidence-based management
work to move your business ahead. "In HR, as in life," Pfeffer says, "we don't
always make decisions based on the facts."
He went on to show how the failure to use evidence hurts companies in everything
they do, from compensating executives and employees to growing and building
the business. In fact, he pointed out that organizational decisions are often
based on:
- What senior leaders have done in the past and think has been effective--their
"experience."
- What others are doing--casual benchmarking.
- Ideology and belief--ideas about how things ought to work.
None of these lead to better decisions, according to Pfeffer, and he called
for organizations to use more evidence-based management to make decisions. He
gave described evidence-based management as:
- A way of thinking--the attitude of wisdom (knowing what you know and knowing
what you don't know) and being willing to act on the basis of what is known
at the time while learning as you act.
- Being committed to "fact-based" and "evidence-based" action.
- Being committed to hearing and telling the truth.
- Treating your organization as an unfinished prototype—and having an
experimenting/learning mind-set.
- Knowing what the theory and evidence are, and using them in formulating
decisions and actions.
- A set of standards for evaluating information and making decisions.
More Pfeffer: He was particularly critical of the famous "forced ranking"
system--used at GE and made famous by Jack Welch--that has managers "grade"
all employees on a curve. The problem is that top performers receive outsized
awards, lower performers get summarily dumped, and the middle group of workers
is largely ignored. This does little, he says, to really improve the business
or the overall performance of the employees.
Vendor angst: Elaine Orler of the Newman Group gave a highly amusing
and informative breakout session on "When and How You Should Switch Recruiting
Vendors." Underlying the talk was her premise that "very rarely is it the right
decision to switch vendors" because it is very expensive to switch platforms
and re-establish a vendor new relationship. She gave three valid reasons for
making a vendor switch:
- The relationship is damaged beyond repair.
- A consolidation of solutions or foundation platforms is needed.
- The company needs a broader application footprint for future success.
She also gave three reasons that are NOT valid justifications to make a switch:
- I liked the product used at my last company better.
- We've changed our business model (again).
- Another vendor promised me a better price.
Speaker you had to see to believe: Conference speakers are a diverse
group, but even having said that, Day 1 lunch speaker Belle Halpern was one
of a kind.
Halpern, founding partner of the Ariel Group, gave her lunch keynote on "Leadership
Presence: Dramatic Techniques to Reach Out, Motivate and Inspire." That sounds
pretty tame, so imagine the audience's surprise when Halpern came out singing
her presentation. Yes, singing--along with piano accompaniment. Just
call her "The Singing Consultant."
She didn't sing her entire presentation, of course, but Halpern's unexpected
and unconventional presentation style was jarring to much of the audience because
it was like one of the old Bill Murray lounge singer skits on Saturday Night
Live. Halpern probably had some good things to say about how you can create
a greater presence to increase the impact of what you say, but the odd and unexpected
singing made a lot of the audience bolt for the doors.
Said one attendee as she got up to leave: "This is absolutely the weirdest
lunch speaker I've ever seen." Or heard.
—John Hollon
Next Article: 8. The Motivation Show 2006--Business Solutions That Motivate People
September 26-28, 2006, McCormick Place South, Chicago
Top of Feature | Features Archive
|
Reproductions and distribution of the above article are strictly prohibited. To order reprints and/or request permission to use the article in full or partial format, please contact our Reprint Sales Manager at (732) 723-0569.
|
|
 |
Feature Contents
Top of Feature
1. Recruiting 2006 Conference and Expo.
November 8-9, Jacob Javits Center, New York City
2. HRO World Europe Annual Conference
November 6-8, the Conrad Hotel, Brussels, Belgium
3. The National Business Coalition on Health Annual Conference
November 5-7, the Astor Crowne Plaza Hotel, New Orleans
4. HR.com Employers of Excellence 2006 Conference
October 24-27, 2006, Red Rock Casino Resort, Las Vegas
5. Oracle OpenWorld 2006
October 22-26, 2006, Moscone Center, San Francisco
6. Pensions & Investments' Seventh Annual West Coast Defined Contribution Conference
October 8-10, 2006, the Fairmont Hotel, San Francisco
7. Human Resource Executive's Ninth Annual HR Technology Conference & Exposition
8. The Motivation Show 2006--Business Solutions That Motivate People
September 26-28, 2006, McCormick Place South, Chicago
9. The Conference Board 2006 Human Resources Outsourcing Conference
September 19-20, the Drake Hotel, Chicago
10. 19th Annual Benefits Management Forum and Expo
September 17-19, Hyatt Regency Hotel, Chicago
11. World Business Forum 2006
September 12-13, Radio City Music Hall, New York City
12. OnRec Expo 2006—Global Summit for Online Recruitment
September 12-13, 2006, at the Donald E. Stephens Convention and Conference Center, Chicago
13. The Conference Board 2006 Hot Topics & Hot Issues HR Forum--Dilemmas, Demographics & Direction
July 18-19, 2006, at the Marriott Marquis Hotel, New York City
14. Workforce Innovations 2006
July 11-13, 2006, Anaheim Convention Center, Anaheim, California
15. Society for Human Resource Management
June 25-28, 2006, Washington, D.C.
16. World Business Forum Chicago 2006
June 6-7, 2006 at Navy Pier, Chicago, Illinois
17. 2006 Workstream User Conference
May 23-24, San Francisco Hilton Financial District, San Francisco
18. The Conference Board 2006 Leadership Development Conference—Developing a New Cadre of Global Leaders for Top-line Growth
May 24-25, 2006, at the Coronado Island Marriott, Coronado, California
19. Vurv Revolution 2006
May 21-24 at Disney's Grand Floridian Resort, Lake Buena Vista, Florida.
20. SAP Sapphire '06
May 16-18, 2006, at the Orange County Convention Center, Orlando, Florida
21. Consumer Directed Health Care Conference and Expo and the National Health, Wellness and Prevention Congress
May 8-10, 2006, at the Hyatt Regency San Francisco
22. WorldatWork Total Rewards Conference & Exhibition 2006
May 7-10, 2006, at the Anaheim Convention Center in Anaheim, California
23. HRO World Annual Conference
April 26-27, 2006, at the New York Hilton & Towers, New York City
24. 2006 Human Resource Planning Society Annual Global Conference
April 23-26, 2006, at the JW Marriott Starr Pass Resort & Spa in Tucson, Arizona.
25. The 2006 World Health Care Congress
April 17-19, 2006, at the Marriott Wardman Park Hotel, Washington, D.C.
26. International Association for Human Resource Information Management
April 9-12, 2006
27. Lawson Software Conference and User Exchange (CUE) 2006
April 9-11, 2006
28. The Conference Board 2006 Senior Human Resources Executive Conference–Strategic Workforce Management and Growth
April 6-7, 2006
|
|
Similar Documents
Related Topics
|
|
Workforce Blogs |
|
The Business of Management
Workforce Management editor John Hollon analyzes and comments on business, management and the art of leading a workforce.
|
|
Workforce Washington
Washington staff writer Mark Schoeff Jr. provides an insider’s insights to the workings of our nation’s capital from the workforce management perspective.
|
|
Global Work Watch
Staff writer Ed Frauenheim blogs about how companies worldwide marshal and manage their workers.
|
|