hen Ohio legislators passed an anti
hen
Ohio legislators passed an anti-gay-marriage law in February that also barred
state agencies from providing benefits to same-sex partners, it wasn’t only gay
activists who protested. Some of the most insistent opposition to the bill came
from companies such as Nationwide Insurance and Limited Brands, Inc., which
operates The Limited, Victoria’s Secret and Bath & Body Works stores. The
employers weren’t motivated so much by the conviction that gays deserved equal
rights as by a more pragmatic concern. They worried that the negative ambience
fostered by the law might hinder their recruiting of gay talent.
Take, for example, NCR Corp., the old-line Ohio company
that made the first mechanical cash register in the 1880s, and has since grown
into a global supplier of computer technology to food warehouses and retail
stores. "We’re based in Dayton, but we’re competing in a global marketplace, not
just for sales but also in hiring and retaining employees," says NCR spokesman
John Hourigan. "Because of that, we see workplace diversity as an imperative."
Hourigan, who is careful to use the politically correct
term "GLBT"--short for gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender--touts NCR’s
efforts to create a workplace that’s attractive to gay job candidates. Not only
does the company offer benefits for same-sex partners and an anti-discrimination
policy, but it also has a company-sanctioned "resource group" of gay employees
who are encouraged to communicate any concerns directly to management.
To make sure that potential job applicants get the message
that the company is gay-friendly, its Web site touts the 2003 "Outie" award that
NCR received from Out & Equal Workplace Advocates, an activist group, and the
company’s second-straight perfect 100 rating for equality from the Human Rights
Campaign, a gay organization in Washington, D.C. NCR has even sponsored a
gay-pride parade in Dayton to increase its visibility in the gay community.
Profits and performance
NCR’s efforts are just one sign of a subtle but growing
trend in the business world. Companies are making a deliberate effort to market
themselves to potential hires as gay-friendly. In some cases, they’re actively
recruiting gay and lesbian talent--by advertising in gay publications,
participating in job fairs run by gay professional and student groups, and
utilizing job-search engines at Web sites such as Gay.com and GayWork.com.
Some turn to a Los Angeles-based recruiting firm,
McCormack and Associates, whose strong links to the gay community are its
calling card. Companies aren’t necessarily investing huge amounts of money in
such efforts--running a corporate visibility ad on the popular Web site
GayWork.com, for example, may cost as little as $6,000 a year--but analysts say
the eventual return on investment may be substantial. That’s because companies
see gay employees as a particularly valuable resource for tapping into the gay
consumer market, which numbers more than 14 million consumers and is projected
to wield more than $607 billion in purchasing power by 2007, according to
MarketResearch.com, in Rockville, Maryland.
It’s not that companies are simply out to hire more gay
workers. Rather, they don’t want to lose out on desirable job candidates who
happen to also be gay, says Daryl Herrschaft, director of the Human Rights
Campaign’s WorkNet program on gay workplace issues. "Companies don’t really care
about sexual orientation. They care about profits and performance. But they know
that GLBT people do care about companies’ policies. If a company has partner
benefits, for example, they tend to see it as an indication of how friendly the
workplace is going to be toward them."
Since by the most generous estimates only 10 percent of
the population is gay, it’s likely that gays amount to a similarly small
fraction of the nation’s workforce. However, that fraction may contain a
disproportionately high number of desirable job candidates, since research
suggests that gays tend to be better educated and more successful professionally
than the population as a whole. A 1996 study by Simmons Market Research Bureau
found that 48 percent of gays had college degrees and 22 percent possessed
advanced degrees, more than three times the proportion in the overall U.S.
population. Seventy percent worked in professional and managerial jobs.
Moreover, the gay population tends to gravitate toward major urban centers, so
it’s more likely that a job applicant in New York or Chicago or Los Angeles will
turn out to be gay. When Richard Florida, a Carnegie Mellon University professor
and visiting scholar at the Brookings Institution, amassed a list in the late
1990s of cities with the hottest high-tech sectors, he noticed that the list
closely matched one that a CMU graduate student had compiled of places with the
highest concentration of gays.
Popular recruiting wisdom holds that gays are concentrated
in certain well-compensated, high-status fields such as investment banking, law
and management. "You get to dress well and eat well in those professions," jokes
recruiting consultant Joseph McCormack. "That’s a lot more fun than, say,
working on software all night and eating from vending machines." Nevertheless,
research by Louis Thomas, an associate professor of management at the University
of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School, suggests that gay workers are distributed
evenly across economic sectors. Thomas has found that 13.4 percent of gays work
in education--one reason why Ohio State University president Karen A. Holbrook
appealed to Ohio Gov. Bob Taft not to sign the anti-gay-marriage bill. Another
7.3 percent work in health care, 7.1 percent in business consulting, 6.4 percent
in government positions, 4.7 percent in manufacturing, 4.6 percent in insurance
and legal work, and 4.2 percent in finance and accounting.
Corporate recruiters, however, are still grappling with
finding the best approach to reaching a group whose members don’t all
necessarily want to be singled out. "A generation ago, being out of the closet
was still anathema at a lot of companies," McCormack says. "Gay workers
basically were looking for a place where they would be left alone, without
harassment." While concern about privacy is still felt by many gays, the latest
generation entering the job market also contains many individuals who’ve been
out since high school and are less reticent about their orientation. It’s not
uncommon, recruiters say, for job applicants to ask about a company’s partner
benefits or nondiscrimination policies.
"Brand loyal"
Nevertheless, those who have studied gay employment
issues say that a company’s reputation for tolerance remains of crucial
importance to applicants. Wharton’s Thomas says his research indicates that gay
employees are likely to stay with an employer with gay-friendly policies, even
if offered more money by a competitor. "GLBTs tend to be brand loyal," says
HRC’s Herrschaft. "They make purchasing decisions based on their perception of a
company’s attitudes. It’s the same thing with jobs."
That makes it imperative for corporate recruiters to
market their company as a gay-friendly brand. Participating in gay job fairs and
conferences is one route. In April, two dozen companies--including such big
names as Ford Motor Co., Sun Microsystems, Citigroup and Morgan Stanley--will be
participating in Reaching Out MBA, a recruiting and networking conference put on
by gay students at the University of Southern California and the University of
California at Los Angeles graduate business schools. Another possibility is the
assortment of gay-oriented Web sites such as GayWork.com in Santa Monica,
California, which maintains profiles of nearly 20,000 job-seekers. More than
1,100 companies, including Microsoft and Capital One Financial Corp., the
McLean, Virginia-based credit card giant, have posted company profiles on the
site. "It’s a way for a company to let everyone know that it’s making the
outreach, that it wants to be a comfortable place," says the site’s founder,
media consultant Matthew Skallerud.
Creating a buzz
Some companies have found, however, that the most
effective way to reach gay talent is through employee referrals and contacts.
NCR, for example, has received tips on possible hires from employees who
participate in its GLBT resource group, a company-sanctioned internal
organization that advises management on gay workplace issues. About half the
companies in the Fortune 500 have established such groups, according to Out &
Equal executive director Selisse Berry.
IBM, widely regarded as one of the most effective
recruiters of gay talent, has gone a step further, using its gay resource group
as an asset in both recruiting and marketing its products. Spokesman Jim
Sinocchi says IBM sees both types of outreach as synergistically serving the
same strategic goal--that is, marketing IBM wares and services to a gay market
segment with an estimated $500 billion in purchasing power. "The nature of the
gay community is strong networks, based on personal contacts, that extend
through peer companies and customers," he says. "What we’re trying to do is
create a buzz, to make people want to spend their money with IBM--or to work
here."
IBM relies on its group of gay employees not just for
referrals, but also to spread the word about the company’s policies and
workplace culture. IBM has 600 employees receiving partner benefits, as well as
25 openly gay executives in key positions throughout the company. In particular,
Sinocchi says, IBM aims to be attractive to gay candidates who are looking for a
workplace in which they can fit in and be open about their orientation.
"Sometimes, gay people looking for jobs aren’t out yet, but maybe they’re hoping
to find a place where they have a chance to come out, or where if people find
out that they’re gay, it isn’t going to hurt their career at all. So we’re
selling IBM as that sort of place."
Emphasizing gay employees’ opportunity to be out in the
workplace has additional benefits for a company once they’re on the job, says
the Wharton School’s Thomas. "GLBT employees are more likely to stay with
employers that offer such policies and benefits even if they are offered a
higher salary from a firm that does not offer these benefits and policies," he
says. "This of course lowers firm retention and recruiting costs."