1. Breaking the Taboo of Firing
A sign that Indian human resource executives have embraced global business practices is not their ability to recruit and train employees but their willingness to fire them.
2. Firms Ratchet Up Efforts to Boost Security
Security is a huge concern in India and is taken seriously by both client and vendor, since Indian companies win contracts that give them access to a client’s proprietary information. Clients often perform random security audits on their Indian vendors.
3. The Right Profile for Worker Loyalty
Recruiting and retention experts in India believe employees who comes from a family of little wealth and grew up in a smaller city where opportunities were limited, are more loyal to their companies. Hiring them is a ticket to lower turnover.
4. Fast Track Greets Indian Returnees
For expatriates, the opportunities in India are particularly abundant. With their technical, cultural and language skills sharpened by years in the American market, Indian repatriates are especially well qualified to bridge the gap between Indian and American workforces.
5. 'Bench' Warmers Often Lack Experience
In India, companies develop a “bench,” because employees, like athletes, must be ready to sub in at a moment’s notice. But since companies require employees to work on a project for as long as a year and a half before moving on to something new, an employee can face months on the company bench with¬out ever actually working.
6. PODCAST: India's New Bargain—Series overview Workforce Management reporter Jeremy Smerd outlines his reporting trip to India and discusses the country's relationship with the U.S. workforce. (Opens a 5MB MP3 audio file. Duration: 4:02 seconds.)
As India’s outsourcing industry moves into performing higher-level work, companies are confronting formidable workforce challenges and waging a battle of hearts and minds to convince their overseas clients that they can be critical business partners.
By Jeremy Smerd Comments 0 | Recommend 0
ANGALORE—In a second-floor office off a dusty street here, computer engineers
are building electronic health records for the American market. It’s just after
6:30 p.m. in late May and the evening snack—dahi vada, a local dish of fried dough
drenched in a sweet yogurt sauce and topped with ground chili—has been served, as
it is every day, to give employees an energy boost as they head into that time of
day when the instant-messenger icons on their computers spring to life.
More than 8,000 miles away, it’s morning in the United States.
Computer engineers at Allscripts Healthcare Solutions, a software company with nearly
1,000 employees, begin to shuffle into the company’s nine U.S. locations. They prepare
to discuss with their Indian counterparts how much progress was made on the project
while the U.S. team was asleep.
The American and Indian engineering teams are not part of
the same company, but in order to take advantage of their 24-hour development cycle,
they must act as one.
The Indian team is HealthAsyst, a small software firm whose
executives happily describe themselves as part and parcel of their American client’s
workforce. This is exactly how Allscripts’ chief executive, Glen Tullman, envisioned
outsourcing his development to India.
"This isn’t about going somewhere and simply getting the lowest
cost," Tullman says via telephone from his company’s Chicago headquarters. "This
is about getting the right talent at the right time."
Though still far cheaper than labor in the U.S., India is
not the bargain it once was, for all the familiar reasons. The economic boom of
the world’s second-fastest-growing economy (9.4 percent growth predicted for 2007)
is straining the infrastructure of major cities, driving up the cost of real estate,
creating salary inflation and setting off talent wars so fierce that a job candidate
who accepts a position on Friday may decide to go with a different company come
Monday. No one is more aware of this than Indian executives and their employees.
Their solution, however, is not to race other outsourcing
countries to the bottom of the economic ladder, but rather to the top. Instead of
being the least expensive place to outsource, they want to offer the greatest value.
And this strategy has changed the value proposition India offers potential customers:
Rather than doing for cheap what they currently do—be it operating call centers,
developing software products or managing a company’s IT infrastructure—Indian companies
want to do more. They want to charge their partners for it and, better yet, share
in the revenue they help create.
There’s one catch: The company that is outsourcing must be
prepared, in many cases, to work more closely with Indian workforces or, at the
very least, see them not as a low-cost, low-skill labor set that operates in a vacuum,
but as an extension of its own workforce. The question for executives of outsourcing
companies, then, is this: Are you ready to commit to India?
"Any company that wishes to outsource must have total clarity
as to why it’s outsourcing," says Rajan Bhandari, a senior manager and retired Indian
navy commander who runs the New Delhi call center of iGate Global Solutions, an
IT outsourcing company that is a subsidiary of Pittsburgh-based iGate Corp. Bhandari
speaks in a tone that is both measured and forceful, and his voice booms over the
hum of the air conditioner inside the company’s New Delhi office.
"Is it outsourcing merely because its bottom line is hurting
and it needs to keep the wolf from the door? That’s fine. It’s OK for the short-term
solution. But these short-term solutions don’t hold for beyond a year because the
wolf will come back to the door with an ever larger appetite."
Business evolution
To develop this clarity, one must first understand that the
history of outsourcing is the story of Indian companies—and their employees—moving
up the value chain.
"When people think of what’s happening in India, they tend
to think it’s low-end coding work and basic-level stuff," says Subash Rao, head
of HR in India for Cisco Systems. "That’s no longer true."
Or at least it is no longer the only truth. Thanks to India’s
history as a British colony, a rich cultural legacy that has long valued education,
especially in the sciences, and the country’s location in a time zone nearly 12
hours away from the U.S., India was uniquely positioned to be the first to take
advantage of outsourcing opportunities.
The seeds for India’s economic boom were planted in 1991 when
the Indian government reversed a closed-door economic policy that had driven away
foreign investment since the late 1970s. This economic liberalization infused the
country with much-needed capital from companies like IBM and General Electric, which
were among the first to take advantage of India’s low-cost talent pool.
The rest of the world awoke to outsourcing in the late 1990s
when Indian companies successfully proved they could manage high-volume, low-skill
work. By fixing a computer’s date with a simple change of code, Indian engineers
helped the world avert the impending doom of Y2K. Such high-volume, low-skill "process
work" moved into other areas. Computer engineers took on projects maintaining and
upgrading old software. Those with a college degree found opportunities, more recently,
in business process outsourcing, doing data-entry processing of auto-insurance and
dental claims.
It can be mind-numbing work, says Ravi Vadapalli, global director
of training and development for Virtusa, an IT consulting firm based in Westborough,
Massachusetts. In his office in Hyderabad, an outsourcing center in southern India
where Microsoft has its Indian headquarters, Vadapalli describes how it can look
to the worker in India: "A thousand dental claims come in. There’s a software here,
I look at something and click. Look at something, click. Look at something, click.
That’s the lowest end. It gets meaningless. I have to work only for the money. So
that’s a huge workplace stress."
Demand for workers and the nature of the work have led to
high employee attrition rates in India, which today average around 40 percent in
business process outsourcing and 15 percent in the higher-skilled IT services.
Meanwhile, the sector is voracious in its need for workers.
In 2007, 1.6 million professionals worked in India’s IT/BPO industry, according
to Nasscom, the industry group representing Indian software companies.
And though nearly 3 million young Indians graduate college
every year, it has become harder and more expensive to recruit for low-end business
processing and information technology work. Nasscom predicts that at current growth
rates, the sector will need 2.3 million workers by 2010 but will have a supply of
only 1.8 million, a shortfall of 500,000 knowledge workers.
Some Indian companies, confident in their ability to train
employees, have begun to hire younger, cheaper workers. ’’
"What they’re saying now is, ‘Guys, you’ve done high school.
That’s enough,’ " Vadapalli says. " ‘You don’t need to go to college; come to my
workplace and I’ll get you a degree.’ "
Many Indian executives worry that India cannot remain competitive
as a country that goes only for the lowest-end, lowest-cost outsourcing contracts.
Salaries alone are cheaper in Vietnam, according to a June 2006 report on global
outsourcing salaries by consulting firm NeoIT in San Ramon, California. In 2006,
salaries increased nearly twice as fast in India (14 percent) than in China and
the Philippines (both 8.1 percent) and Thailand (6.5 percent), Hew¬itt Associates
reported in its annual compensation survey.
"When people think of what's happening in India, they tend to think it's low-end coding work and
basic-level stuff. That's no longer true." --Subash Rao, head of HR in India, Cisco
India’s IT sector is predicted to generate $47.8 billion in
revenue in 2007, more than doubling from $21.6 billion in 2004. The great majority
of that revenue—an estimated $39.4 billion in 2007—comes from outsourcing contracts,
so Indian companies hope that such results will prompt their overseas clients to
stay with them even as their services grow in cost and complexity. So far, if revenue
growth is any measure, this transition to higher-end work has already begun.
"The world is slowly waking up to Indian talent," says Ameet
Nivsarkar, vice president of Nasscom. "Over a matter of time, managers have realized
the value the Indian workforce can bring to their team, and there is a significant
amount of high-end work that is being shared."
Business process outsourcer 24/7 Customer is based in Los
Gatos, California, but the bulk of its 5,000 employees are offshore. To that company,
creating value means using analytical modeling to make predictions about a customer’s
buying habits and shaping its own workforce in accord with those findings.
Vasudevan Bharathwaj, chief marketing officer at 24/7 Customer,
describes what a medium-sized online retailer could learn from his company. (Bharathwaj
would not name his clients, but think of janitorial supply company ReStockIt.com
or New York-based electronics company J&R Electronics.)
For example, a middle-age man calling Bangalore from Los Angeles
around 6 p.m. PST has a higher likelihood of buying the latest computer gadgetry
if he’s talking to an Indian cyber-salesman who hails from a small city and whose
father was a low-level government bureaucrat. Bharathwaj says 24/7’s statistical
analysis shows that young salesmen from smaller cities whose parents did not make
a lot of money make better salesmen, especially when the customer is male. He thinks
some Americans, who may know nothing about the Indian sales force, may connect in
an unspoken way with such a salesman and therefore be motivated to buy from him.
The goal of using this kind of analysis is to create intellectual
property—predicting consumer behavior, for example—that clients can use to generate
revenue to be shared with 24/7.
The drive to create greater value is especially true in product
development. HCL Technologies, a New Delhi-based technology company with 43,000
employees worldwide and $1.27 billion in revenue last year, calls its approach "co-sourcing."
HCL, which offers pro¬duct engineering, IT services and business
pro¬cess outsourcing, tends to keep a low profile. Most of the world doesn’t know
that the company’s engineers helped develop Microsoft’s Vista operating system and
the computer technology on Boeing’s new 787 Dreamliner. In a typical arrangement,
about 1,200 HCL employees work on a networking project for Cisco Systems’ office
in Bangalore. In every way except their paycheck, they are Cisco employees.
Whether the client is in Denver or Delhi, interaction between
the two workforces has increased fifty-fold, from quarterly communication to daily
interactions, says Vineet Nayar, president of HCL Technologies.
"The question of the two workforces interacting has become
by far the most important element in the success of a project," Nayar says.
Building soft skills
Integrating the two workforces, if only by instant messenger,
still requires a large measure of communication, analysis and discretionary decision
making. As a result, a focus on softer skills has permeated most Indian companies.
At Wipro Technologies’ 120-acre Bangalore headquarters, a
leather-bound copy of Stephen Covey’s The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People stands
out against the stack of computer software manuals like a Bible on a newsstand.
But the self-help book is there for a reason.
"Five years ago, our focus was on technical skills, writing
code," says Selvan Dora¬i¬raj, Wipro’s senior vice president for training. "Today,
50 percent of our effort is there, on coding. The rest is on consultant training,
management skills, customer-facing skills."
Wipro invests 1 percent of its revenue in training. In 2006,
the company spent $18 million—or 1 percent of its $1.8 billion in revenue from its
global IT services and products division—on training materials and personnel, including
seminars that go along with Covey’s book, and 75 courses on technical and management
skills. The company has more than 140 teachers, 30 of whom are certified professional
behavior analysts. Their job, in part, is to teach employees how to better interact
with clients so as to avoid the cultural miscues that can easily metastasize from
annoyances into crises.
"The purpose of this training is to combat the ‘Indian wiggle,’
" says Gurudutt Rao, a trainer for Wipro. The term refers to the way Indians nod
their head side to side to say yes. It’s a gesture that could be construed in the
U.S. as shaking one’s head to say no. It is also a larger metaphor for the importance
of bridging cultures to communicate effectively.
Desire to make a difference
The march of Indian companies up the value chain is, in many
ways, an ineluctable product of ambition and necessity.
"There is a lot of fire-in-the-belly syndrome in India today,"
says Prabir Jha, global chief of human resources for Indian pharmaceutical company
Dr. Reddy’s Laboratories. "Indian companies really want to take on the world."
Nowhere is this more evident than in the changing expectations
young Indian workers have for their careers.
"The current workforce is highly ambitious in terms of their
career," Wipro’s Dorairaj says. "If they are not satisfied, they will continue to
move on."
Money is but one part of that decision. After working nearly
four years for a small software company in Calcutta, Saptarshi Roy thought he’d
gotten his big break. In 2006, he landed a job with the title of senior software
engineer with Wipro Technologies’ Bangalore campus.
Roy, 29, quickly discovered that his lofty job title didn’t
accurately reflect the work he was doing, which was the simple, almost rote computer
work of checking for bugs in software that runs the printers, scanners and other
hardware of Wipro’s Japanese client Toshiba. It was precisely the kind of process-driven
quality-assurance job that has fueled India’s outsourcing boom. But it was boring.
"The job was very low-end," he says.
Six months later, he quit. Roy ended up at Health¬Asyst. This
summer he spent a month working at Allscripts’ office in Libertyville, Illinois,
near Chicago. During that brief stay, he visited New York City, which, he wrote
in an e-mail, "rockz."
Allscripts’ decision to outsource was driven by the need to
bring products to market faster. From the start, the company saw that the best way
to develop products faster was to treat its Indian vendor as a partner.
"We want to treat them as if they’re part of the company,
because if we are paying them to do something they are critical to the company,"
says Tullman, who in addition to being CEO of Allscripts is an Oxford University-trained
social anthropologist and has traveled to India nine times. "You are never going
to get the same level of success as when you treat them as a partner."
Clearly, not all companies are looking to India to help develop
new products. If all companies want is a less expensive way to manage payroll and
other back-office functions, or if they perceive India’s ambition to move up the
value chain as a threat to them and their onshore employees, they won’t have the
commitment needed to make India work, Indian executives say. Executives who want
to successfully outsource to India must be committed to seeing the work mature,
and they must prepare their own workforce to move up the value chain alongside their
vendors, iGate’s Bhandari says.
"A successful offshoring effort is when employees grow and
the seats they’ve left are filled by their offshoring partner," he says.
The conference room has grown quiet. At nearly 10 p.m., the
sun has long since set on this muggy May night. The incessant honking of cars and
the 100-degree heat outside have finally begun to dissipate. Then Ritu Arora, a
divisional head of learning and development at iGate, sitting next to Bhandari,
explains that point further. With a smile on her face, she aims to convert the skeptical:
American executives who commit to India, who see the Indian workforce as an extension
of one’s own, would reap the greatest rewards for their risk.
"Then the team here feels a critical part of the work," she
says. "We feel that we matter, that we are recognized, and that the work we do makes
a difference."
Workforce Management, August 20, 2007, p. 1, 22-32
-- Subscribe Now!
Jeremy Smerd is a Workforce Management staff writer based in New York. E-mail editors@workforce.com to comment.
Next Article: 1. Breaking the Taboo of Firing
A sign that Indian human resource executives have embraced global business practices is not their ability to recruit and train employees but their willingness to fire them.
Reproductions and distribution of the above article are strictly prohibited. To order reprints and/or request permission to use the article in full or partial format, please contact our Reprint Sales Manager at (732) 723-0569.
Comments
Guidelines: Comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate comments or material will be removed
from the site. We will take steps to block users who violate any of our posting standards, terms of use or privacy policies
or any other policies governing this site. You are fully responsible for the content you post.