Employer-sponsored health care premiums increased 5 percent this year, a
relatively modest gain attributable largely to savings made by the adoption of
plans with high deductibles and less generous coverage for employees, according
to a health benefits survey published Wednesday, September 24.
Despite the slowdown in health insurance rate increases, premiums have more
than doubled since 1999, according to an annual survey by the Henry J. Kaiser
Family Foundation and the Health Research and Educational Trust. Researchers
believe rates could spike next year due to the lagging economy, forcing the
number of employers offering coverage to drop.
“We’ve seen peaks and valleys in premiums before,” said Drew Altman,
president and CEO of the Kaiser foundation. “There is no evidence we’ve done
much if anything to deal with the fundamental underlying drivers of health care
costs. So this valley won’t last.”
Kaiser’s annual study is seen by researchers as among the most comprehensive.
This year the study’s authors published a companion article online in the
journal Health Affairs.
Researchers said the economic slowdown came after companies had made their
health plan decisions for 2008, but they expect a combination of higher
premiums, less generous coverage and fewer firms able to offer coverage next
year.
“We may be seeing a tip of the iceberg of a trend toward less-comprehensive,
skimpy health insurance for working people, with higher premiums and
out-of-pocket costs,” Altman said.
Family plans now cost, on average, $12,680 annually, up from $5,791 in 1999.
In the same period, workers’ wages grew 34 percent and general inflation rose 29
percent, Employers’ costs have increased 119 percent; workers now pay on average
$3,354 for a family plan, up from $1,543 in 1999, a 117 percent increase.
The rising costs have hit small employers (fewer than 200 employees) hardest.
Many have turned to high-deductible health plans, which tend to have lower
premiums, in order to offer health insurance to their workers.
The percentage of small employers offering health insurance hit a nadir of 45
percent last year but rebounded to 49 percent in 2008, according to the
survey.
The survey also found that 35 percent of covered workers at companies with
fewer than 200 employees face annual deductibles of $1,000 or more, more than
doubling from 16 percent in 2006. Overall, 18 percent of employees face
deductibles of more than $1,000.
An estimated 5.5 million workers, or 8 percent, are enrolled in
consumer-directed plans—which offer a health savings account or health
reimbursement arrangement—up from 5 percent last year.
Small firms showed the largest gain in this category, with 13 percent of
covered employees at such companies enrolled in consumer-directed plans, up from
8 percent last year. Sixty percent of small companies said cost was the primary
reason for switching to consumer-directed plans; 40 percent said their greatest
challenge was communicating with employees about the change.
Deductibles also rose sharply for employees in more traditional forms of
health insurance. Deductibles in PPOs, or preferred provider organizations, in
which 58 percent of employees are covered, rose nearly $100, to an average of
$560, in 2008.
The percentage of large employers (200 or more employees) offering retiree
health benefits declined to 31 percent, statistically unchanged since last year,
when 33 percent offered the benefit. In 1988, 66 percent of large employers
offered retiree health benefits.
Employers are increasingly trying to reduce health care costs by improving
the health of their employees by creating wellness programs.
Half of all firms offer at least one type of wellness initiative, such as
weight-loss programs, gym-membership discounts or on-site exercise facilities,
smoking-cessation programs, personal-health coaching, classes in nutrition or
healthy living, Web-based resources for healthy living, or a wellness
newsletter. Few firms, however, offer incentives for enrolling in wellness
programs.
The survey of nearly 2,000 employers was conducted in the first five months
of this year. At that time, 24 percent of employees identified paying for health
insurance and medical care as a serious problem, ranking third behind paying for
gas and finding a good-paying job or getting a pay raise. At the time the survey
was taken this spring, most employers said they were likely to offer health
benefits next year.
—Jeremy Smerd
Workforce Management's online news feed is now
available via Twitter.